Series
.

Is Tay Done?

April 29, 2024
Our resident Swiftie expert Camila Dejesus takes on the claims that Taylor Swift’s latest album is a flop.
Show transcript
00:00
Sister be real with me.
00:01
Are you sick of Taylor Swift?
00:04
I mean, I'm not sick of her.
00:07
I mean, I feel like she's just been like,
00:09
very popular. I hear her everywhere but I'm not sick of
00:12
her. It's interesting because Taylor Swift has a new album out
00:15
right? The Tortured Poets Department,
00:17
right? And it's breaking sales records and on paper,
00:20
it's doing good, but people aren't necessarily big fans of it
00:26
Wait. But what if it's doing good?
00:27
But then people aren't big fans of,
00:29
I mean, the fandom is crazy and you ask them and
00:32
it's apparently getting different reviews.
00:34
So apparently their recent album scored as low as J Lo's album
00:38
on Pitchfork. Oh,
00:39
shoot. So again,
00:42
all these conflicting the numbers and Taylor Swift,
00:46
but we're gonna bring The Swifty back on to join us and
00:50
break this all down for us,
00:51
Camila. Can you please break down what's happening in the Taylor
00:53
verse? Hey, Camila,
00:55
welcome. How are you?
00:58
I am doing great as a Swift.
01:01
It has been going pretty good over here now.
01:03
Oh, interesting. Ok.
01:06
Because we were talking about the album and we've heard different opinions
01:09
right? Some people say it's a dud but is this
01:12
like a, just a haters gonna hate no matter what she
01:14
does or is this album not like her best work?
01:18
Ok. I think that's a really interesting question because like,
01:21
a lot of artists have a lot of fans and then the
01:24
people outside of those fan bases typically don't like that music.
01:28
That's why they're not fans of that artist,
01:30
but you don't hear it because no one really cares.
01:33
Like, if you think of like Billie Eilish,
01:35
if you don't like Billie Eilish music,
01:36
you're just kind of like,
01:37
OK, and that's really it,
01:38
you move on. So I love the album.
01:41
I think the people that it was intended for really like it
01:44
I think it is a great album but I don't think
01:47
it's for everyone and I think that's OK.
01:49
I don't think everyone needs to love it,
01:51
but I don't know why everyone is being so mean to those
01:54
that do, which I've definitely noticed.
01:57
So, yeah, I don't know.
01:58
It's why and why do you feel the need to kind of
02:01
make people that do enjoy something feel bad?
02:04
It's just kind of strange to me that's social media,
02:07
dude for you. It's like,
02:10
dude just keeps growing like it just keeps growing.
02:12
You don't like, it just keeps growing.
02:15
So like, it's kinda reminds me like a bad bunny situation
02:17
kind of in the last couple of albums.
02:18
It was like, it's more like reggaeton now,
02:20
he's getting into like his,
02:21
you know, softball era and then he's getting back to like
02:23
the trap music. Like,
02:24
so with Taylor Swift,
02:25
you mentioned that this album is made for specific people.
02:29
Like, so what?
02:30
It's just a lot because it's like,
02:32
yes it is, you should be able to go to any
02:34
album and yeah, you can appreciate it.
02:35
That's great. It is great music.
02:37
It has a great message,
02:38
but it's this album more than most is like diary entry level
02:42
of like this is what has been happening in the past three
02:45
years. And so it references a lot of older songs and
02:48
it references a lot of her life in the last six years
02:51
really and ties back to all these things that you wouldn't necessarily
02:55
know about if you weren't in that fan base or like it
02:58
is so deep, it goes like 10 years deep into this
03:02
lure of all these relationships and all this stuff.
03:05
And if you don't know that you're not going to get as
03:07
much from it, which is totally fine,
03:08
it just isn't intended.
03:10
Like it was written from her perspective as a person who knows
03:13
all of that. It's kind of like a lower based album
03:16
in a way people are talking about some of the lyrics being
03:20
like dense. That's what people are saying.
03:23
Is this thoughtful artist or like,
03:25
is this thoughtful artistic expression or is she being like pretentious?
03:30
That's what I mean?
03:30
That's what some people are saying.
03:32
I don't know. Ok.
03:33
Ok. I, I think it's really thoughtful.
03:36
It is really funny because the whole point is called to tortured
03:39
poets. I mean,
03:40
obviously I'm a swifty.
03:41
So if you disagree that's great,
03:42
you know, have fun with that.
03:44
But,, I like it and also as a writer
03:48
I think it's amazing because it's more literary.
03:51
I mean, she has a doctorate now for her writing.
03:53
So I think it makes sense.
03:55
But she also has really silly songs,
03:57
the songs she wrote about Travis are very,
03:59
not lyrically deep, but they're really cute and really fun.
04:03
So I think it just depends.
04:04
But again, that might not be for you.
04:06
You might not, you might like more of like a poppy
04:08
boppy moment and that's totally great.
04:10
It's just not the vibe of this general album is more,
04:13
definitely more lyrically intense.
04:15
It's a little silly goose sometimes.
04:17
And so it sounds like people might just be hating because they
04:20
have that fomo honestly because it's such a deep connection to like
04:24
the early stuff that like,
04:25
if you don't know,
04:25
you don't know. I'm,
04:26
I'm sorry. So people are probably like,
04:28
maybe jealous that they're like,
04:29
I'm not in that Swifty club but I don't want to anyways
04:31
But like the album is mid,
04:33
it's like, well,
04:33
you don't know what we're talking about.
04:34
So, but then I would also question like Taylor Swift is
04:37
never gonna see you be,
04:38
see you kind of being mean.
04:40
So then it's like,
04:41
what are you getting out of kind of being like,
04:44
oh, this music is trash and saying it to someone who
04:46
specifically loves that music that inherently outside of Taylor Swift is just
04:50
a mean thing to do if you really love bad bunny and
04:53
someone walked up to you and was like,
04:54
he's garbage. It's just not a nice way to meet someone
04:58
So I would just say maybe put some more thought into
05:00
how you interact with people because it's,
05:03
it's a little sad sometimes.
05:06
Yeah. But what's something about this album that people aren't talking
05:10
about? OK. So this isn't something necessarily that a lot
05:15
of people aren't talking about.
05:16
But I have seen a lot of people be like,
05:18
this is your lyrical genius.
05:20
And then they'll take a song from like there's a song
05:23
called So High School written about Travis that is very adorable and
05:26
very sweet. And they'll take a lyric from that and kind
05:28
of be like, OK,
05:29
this is a really childish lyric,
05:31
which is the point because it's supposed to be about.
05:33
It feels like a love when you're in high school.
05:35
So that's what it's written about.
05:36
But a lot of people don't dig deeper.
05:39
There's a song called Peter on the album that is absolutely beautiful
05:43
It's written from Wendy's perspective and the Peter Pan narrative and
05:47
it's essentially a poem it's absolutely gorgeous.
05:50
Just about Wendy getting older and Peter Pan never really coming
05:54
back to be with her.
05:56
And it's really heartbreaking and I think if you're kind of
05:59
one of those people that's like,
06:00
lyrically, this is garbage,
06:01
I would definitely recommend listening to that song,
06:05
I don't think it's getting enough love and I think it's a
06:07
really, really great song.
06:08
I want a good cry.
06:09
So maybe like on the way home,
06:10
I'll put that one on it.
06:15
Are you OK? I'm always down for a good cry.
06:19
Thank you so much Camila.
06:20
We really appreciate you being on the show and,
06:22
and giving us more insight about Taylor Swift and,
06:25
and her new album.
06:26
Where can people find you,
06:27
Camila? You can find me all over.
06:29
I'm on Instagram at camila.underscore.de Jesus or I'm also a magazine
06:36
editor for Latinas magazine.org.
06:38
We're a great nonprofit.
06:39
So check us out.
06:40
Thank you so much Camila.
06:42
You take care and have a good one.
06:43
Ok. You too.
06:45
Thanks. Bye.